HEADER FOR Expressions
(Click picture to go back to Table of Contents)

Welcome

Enjoy... But remember
"Don't give in to winning the argument
and losing one of your eternal crowns..."

God bless you...   tell your friends

Next-in-Thread Next Message

Disagree There you have proof that Rome has gone apostate from very early on! 

Forum: Theological Expressions
Re: None Catholic Principles on Ecumenism (Vatican II, Decree on Ecumenism) (Matthew Tan Yew Hock)
Re: Disagree Already Rebutted http://www.antioch.com.sg/cgi-bin/Agora-Pub/get/expressions/95/3/3/1.html (Christopher Yip)
Re: None Folly of Self-Interpretation, and Careless and Incomplete Reading (Matthew Tan Yew Hock)
Re: Disagree Already rebutted again! (eom) (Christopher Yip)
Re: None A rebuttal that is not. (Matthew Tan Yew Hock)
Re: Disagree You must be referring to YOUR own. (Christopher Yip)
Re: None The Text and Context: Unam Sanctam. (No Salvation Outside The Church, Proper Interpretation - cont'd) (Matthew Tan Yew Hock)
Re: None Pope Pius IX: Fuller Teaching on "No Salvation Outside The Church" (Matthew Tan Yew Hock)
Re: More More on Pope Pius IX, and other Popes' teaching on this... (Matthew Tan Yew Hock)
Date: 2001, Apr 25
From: Christopher Yip CKHY

It is quite clear that Rome teaches salvation EITHER THROUGH HER DOORS or THROUGH CONSCIENCE in contradiction to what the bible teaches - salvation is through faith alone in Christ alone.

The evidence presented to us by anti-Protestant Mr Tan demonstrates that Rome has gone apostate for a very long time now.

Rome's claims, when tested against Scriptures, have been found to be erroneous over and over again.

Just one more point.

It doesn't hurt us nor does it matter to us whether Rome regards us, by way of concession, to be saved. It seems to me that Rome is aware of the silliness of the position she has taken on the "no salvation outside Rome" issue. And to save her reputation, she now explains that although she is still the mother Church, the one true Church, we may still be saved outside of her and this is because we are "invincibly ignorant" of her true status.

Now, this is a very good way to deflect any objections. It satisfies everyone. Look, Rome says, we are still the only true Church but you can be saved even though you oppose us like mad. It's just that you are ignorant of our true status. You are okay even though you are outside of our communion but you are sort-of like having only half the full blessing of being a Christian.

This is almost an irrefutable position! It is like the pu-dao-ong (the never-falling-man) - no matter how you beat it, it bounces back. You just can't hit it down.

The problems with this position are first, ANY DENOMINATION can take this position and second, strange that the bible does not mention one iota about submission to Rome especially since without her, we cannot be saved.

On the first point, if the Greek Orthodox Church, claiming Andrew to be their founder, says the same thing as Rome, why should we take either of their word? Roman Catholics provide no biblical or historical evidences to substantiate their claims. Sure, they TRY to provide evidence but as we have seen in this board, every one of them cannot hold water!

On the second point, contrast this with the Gospel. In every one of NT book, the Gospel is given PRIME PROMINENCE and it is clear that the writers strove to ensure that their readers put first thing first which is the GOSPEL. Be it Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Peter, Paul or James - to them, it was paramount that the GOSPEL be preached because they knew that without it, men would not be saved. But when it came to "no salvation outside Rome"- not a word is mentioned. Even in the Church Fathers' writing, there is not a word that says salvation is through the doors of Rome, through her sacraments, through her penances and absolution. Nope. Nothing. Zero. Now, doesn't it make you wonder that something as important as this is not mentioned at all for the first 1000 years?

Rome is bankrupt historically!

Christopher.

Next-in-Thread Next Message

Add Message to: "There you have proof that Rome has gone apostate from very early on!"

Members Subscribe Admin Mode Show Frames Help for Agora Public 1.10

Messages Inline: 1 All Outline: 1 2 3

1. None Read Romans 13:1-2, John 20:23, Matt 16:19, Matt 18:17-18. eom. by Matthew Tan Yew Hock, 2001, Jun 12
(_ Disagree What They Say in Context. by Christopher Yip, 2001, Jun 12

Add Message to: "There you have proof that Rome has gone apostate from very early on!"

Members Subscribe Admin Mode Show Frames Help for Agora Public 1.10
FOOTER for Expressions

tell your friends

Copyright © 1996, 1997, 1998,1999, 2000, 2001 Antioch Networks International. All Rights Reserved.
The Agora Forum is a registered trademark of Antioch Networks International.

Thank you for contributing to Expressions!

Back to Antioch's Home Page
For more information, please send your request to: forumaster@antioch.com.sg.