HEADER FOR Expressions
(Click picture to go back to Table of Contents)

Welcome

Enjoy... But remember
"Don't give in to winning the argument
and losing one of your eternal crowns..."

God bless you...   tell your friends

Next-in-Thread Next Message

None Wrong way 

Forum: Theological Expressions
Re: Note We need changed hearts, not miracles. (Wahshing)
Re: Sad Why many kept calling myJesus,a false healer,today?
Re: Warning It's time to come back from "Experience" to Scriptures! (Christopher Yip)
Re: Warning All those queries and distortions were refuted long ago!Here's more.
Re: None "Refuted"? You mean "rancour", don't you? (Christopher Yip)
Re: News I oblige You. (FrankieLee)
Re: None And I am STILL waiting ... (Christopher Yip)
Re: Disagree Please be open and I assume you are reasonable.1. (FrankieLee)
Re: None But unfortunately, you are not. (Christopher Yip)
Re: Ok Superficial or deep,at a glance? (FrankieLee)
Re: Ok Frank and Chris, pls read, thankyou (Emmanuel)
Re: None Nope. (Christopher Yip)
Re: Question Hi Chris, I have a question for people who cessationists (Royston Ong)
Re: Agree On Cessationism (Christopher Yip)
Re: Ok In so saying.... (Royston Ong)
Date: 2001, Sep 06
From: Christopher Yip CKHY

Dear Royston,

If we go even further back, we can also say no point having any discussion or debate at all since all Christians, even most cults, agree that we are saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone. If we use this instead as the baseline, why then do we still discuss about baptism, about the nature of faith, etc?

YOU: Helped to clarify some views. In so saying, is it not clear then that all of us who call ourselves Christians, would fall into a Cessationist stand as a baseline or a benchmark, because the Cessationist's stand holds that God is the ultimate healer?

ME: Okay if you wish to focus on this. There are also other POA: that God answers prayers for healing, that God sometimes use objects, other times just direct healing, etc. There is a lot of common ground but if you wish to focus only on the common ground and thus call all charismatics basically cessationists, it's fine with me. I doubt, however, the charismatics would be happy. It seems you still haven't grasp the main difference between a GIFT and answer to prayer.

YOU: If this being the case, what probably defers for those who are Pentacostals.... I would actually avoid lumping Charismatics along with Pentacostals..... would be their exercising of their faith individually to see a miracle occur in their lifetime.

ME: That would be a cessationist's position. ALl of us are to pray for each other's needs, some of which call for a miracle. We are to exercise faith and at the same time, let God decide. That's perfectly fine with cessationism.

BUT when someone stands up and declares, "God wants you to be healed, come and receive the healing ..." apparently from this person who possess the "gift" of healing as the apostles did. This means the person KNOWS that God has decided to heal this person and RIGHT NOW, and it is through him/her. These are characteristics of biblical gift of healing. And when that healing fails, and since this person has the gift which cannot fail (the bible never documents any case of such failed healing by those who have the gift), then it must be something wrong with the seeker.

Grasp this key difference.

YOU: Then, since this being the case, why do we need to argue or debate over this issue of healing.... certainly it goes to show, all of us are in agreement from the viewpoint of the benchmark and baseline. Which to me is the bottomline to our faith. If God wishes to encourage us and to build/increase our faith, by healing someone miraculously, then it is His choice after all, right?

So likewise, when viewed from the perspective of God, it is probably God's will to continue healing, but all is in His timing. Is it not?

ME: Again, this is what cessationists believe but not charismatics who believe that the gift of healing exists today.

Perhaps there are those of you who consider yourself charismatic when in fact you hold to the above which are clearly cessationist's view. I'm glad for you and feel that you should now take that stand.

Regards,

Christopher

Next-in-Thread Next Message

Add Message to: "Wrong way"

Members Subscribe Admin Mode Show Frames Help for Agora Public 1.10

Messages Inline: 1 All Outline: 1 2 3

1. Ok Please correct me if I have not yet figured it out by Royston Ong, 2001, Sep 09
(_ None Response by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 09
1. Note Hi Chris by Royston Ong, 2001, Sep 09
1. None You still have a few strawman arguments which I rebutted but you are getting there. (eom) by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 12
2. Note Ahhh I see your point now and I wonder whether Frankie can share his by Royston Ong, 2001, Sep 12
3. None Save-by-grace gave good response. by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 12
1. Idea Ok maybe to avoid another Theological debate between you and Chris by Royston Ong, 2001, Sep 12
1. Feedback Die hard fans,of the fallacies! by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 13
(_ More Hi Frankie by Royston Ong, 2001, Sep 13
1. Feedback Gifts of Healing? by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 14
2. Idea ONE point ,for clarity first. by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 14
1. Idea Please get a copy of A Diary of Signs & Wonders by Maria Woodworth-Etter. That book speaks volume. eom by saved-by-grace, 2001, Sep 14
2. None From a cessationist named Frankie. by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 13
1. Disagree Frankielee....this is utter nonsense! (But USA is top priority now) eom by saved-by-grace, 2001, Sep 13
1. None Pls do not blame Frankie or Chris, if you wish to blame you can blame me instead by Royston Ong, 2001, Sep 13
1. Feedback explanation by saved-by-grace, 2001, Sep 14
2. Agree Glad that you think so! Now, go look at Frankie's responses to mine. Familiar? (eom) by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 13
2. Disagree Jack Deere knocked down too many fallacies. by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 14
1. None One point to illustrate,Jack Deere says... by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 14
1. Disagree blah blah blah ... in the end, BLANK! Rebut this, Frank. by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 15
(_ Warning Chris,it is time you surrender,and be silent. by FrankieLee, 2001, Sep 16
(_ Angry Frank, go enrol yourself for study and stop misleading people with your ill-logic and unbiblical teachings. by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 16
2. Disagree ... until you BLUR? by Christopher Yip, 2001, Sep 15
3. Note I retract for the record of Truths. by Frank, 2001, Oct 07

Add Message to: "Wrong way"

Members Subscribe Admin Mode Show Frames Help for Agora Public 1.10
FOOTER for Expressions

tell your friends

Copyright © 1996, 1997, 1998,1999, 2000, 2001 Antioch Networks International. All Rights Reserved.
The Agora Forum is a registered trademark of Antioch Networks International.

Thank you for contributing to Expressions!

Back to Antioch's Home Page
For more information, please send your request to: forumaster@antioch.com.sg.